That one
night: she thought he was proposing; he thought they were breaking up.
Was there
someone else?
Not yet.
“Much more
than I ever hated Joel, I came to hate this nameless, faceless woman. I wanted
to get back at him for what he did to me. That was my intention from the
beginning. When Joel dumped me that night, he took away my entire
life—my home, my
friends, my dignity.
I could never get
any of that
back. All I wanted was to even
the score. I never meant to kill anyone. I swear.” (11)
Present day:
Twenty-six year old Cassie is struggling to make her family’s bookstore
business thrive again. The last thing she had time for was a relationship. Then
in walks HD (Hot Doctor A.K.A. Joel.)
Meanwhile,
the Ex quietly stands aside and waits…waits to see what Joel does and where he
goes…just waits for him to come back.
“Is he
embarrassed that his
new girlfriend is
apparently a dead
ringer for his
old girlfriend?” (50) That’s kind of a creep factor.
I thought
this story was interesting. It had that frightening suspense angle of the
psychotic ex, but it also had that touch of human empathy because you also get the ex’s side of the
story, which relayed her loss, loneliness, and financial (and mental)
instability.
It’s truly a
rarity for me to like all the characters in a book. I liked Cassie’s love for
books and her resolve to save the bookstore; I felt bad about the Ex’s money
troubles and feared that she may end up in the street. I felt Cassie’s euphoric
high at starting a new relationship, hoping the two would last; and I felt the
Ex’s growing jealousy and resentment, hoping the two would break up. Since the
book is written in the POV’s of the Ex and the New Girl, you feel for and enjoy
these characters the most. The diary format can sometimes be too explicit,
exacerbating the drama more than it should. Obsession is the key element here
and the two girls have a lot of it. In fact, they torture themselves with it,
and you hear all about it in their “diary”—it can get a little tiring
sometimes. I mean, it’s clear that they
both had crazy issues. The constant shift between the two POV’s did slow down
the pace in what follows for a standard psychological thriller. I wish it
would’ve had more action and less whining. I wouldn’t necessarily say it was
“unputdownable,” as indicated on the retail page, but it’s still pretty good.
My rating: 3.5 stars
Intriguing twists but very shallow characters.
ReplyDeleteI thought it was too messy trying to understand the timeliness at the end. I figured "the ex" was someone other than Francesca, but towards the end it seemed like a rush to tie it all together.
ReplyDeleteI can’t tie the ending together? Please please explain.
DeleteI am having the same issue
DeleteMe as well… I feel I need to go back and read last couple of chapter's again to get my head straight as to what’s going on but I’m almost over it and will just move on.
DeleteYeah loved it till I got to the end, felt like it was meant to be an ohhhhhhhhhh moment but I just didn’t get it, I may just be stupid tho
ReplyDeleteI was very confused at the end. Was it supposed to be Lydia who broke into the book store and Cassie’s apartment and wrote the slur? Where did she get the keys?
ReplyDeleteThank you!! These little details and holes in the story drove me crazy ..I just finished the book. How exactly did Lydia get in her apartment? When the entire narrative on the stolen keys was technically years earlier by Ana…the book literally made no sense.
DeleteI also couldn't understand the ending either and I reread it two times already still I didn't understand it. its a bit confusing tbh.....
ReplyDeleteThe ex must be Anna and not Francesca. It’s hard to figure out whose speaking at times.
ReplyDeleteI also am very confused. I went back and started reading it again, but still in question. I told my daughter she has to read it and see if she understands so she can explain to me. LOL
ReplyDeleteWell I’m so glad to know that it’s not just me. I’m 69 years old and have read way more books in my lifetime that I can remember. I love a twist at the end of a book but this one made no sense to me. I was going to read it again but now I’m not going to waste my time.
ReplyDeleteIt really confused me too but after a lot of thought I'm thinking it never was francesca speaking at all as Anna killed her and she had a totally different accent. The ex was always Anna. But I'm unable to think why Lydia done stuff too as if it was the ex doing it. I'd need to go back and listen to see if it says 'the ex' at the start of that chapter. But I won't as I think it was a poor job of trying to create a shocking ending. It could have been done a lot better and at the same timeline instead of going back and forwards without even letting the listeners know.
ReplyDelete